Read time: 7 mins

Ploy

I had two CSV files and no idea what came next

I'd scored 134 B2B brands across 24,348 pieces of content, and all of it sat in two spreadsheets. I thought, now what?

So I uploaded both into Ploy. Its agent pulled out the findings and built the site around them, with a landing page, a methodology page and a custom report page for every brand I reviewed.

The whole benchmark took three weeks, start to finish.

Brand Chemistry readers get 50% off the first month with code Isaac-Peiris.

Thank you for supporting our sponsors, who keep this newsletter free.

Your Brand, One Character Long

A killer product and a great story will only carry a brand so far. Staying in people’s heads is a separate fight, and it’s a fight over a tiny, very expensive plot of land just behind your customer’s forehead (the prefrontal cortex, for the anatomy nerds). One of the sneakiest ways to win it is to pick an emoji and make it yours. Call it a mental shortcut, one that leads your audience straight back to you.

Think about the golden arches. You spot them from the highway, and your brain has said ‘McDonald’s’ before you’ve finished reading the sign—and your stomach usually isn’t far behind. The right emoji can pull off the same trick and spark instant recognition. That reflex is exactly what we’re chasing: Repetition. Recognition. Recall.

Morning Brew and beehiiv have turned this into an art form. One emoji, used everywhere, over and over, until the brand and the symbol became the same thing in their audience’s minds. Nail the strategy, and you can pull it off too.

I'm Bill Kerr, founder of Athyna and the Open Source CEO newsletter. Isaac has invited me back to break down more about emoji ownership. Let’s dive in.

How 176 tiny pictures took over the world

Rewind to the 90s. If you wanted to put some feeling into a message, you were stuck with emoticons like :) or kaomoji like ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Then, in 1999, a Japanese engineer named Shigetaka Kurita designed a set of 176 little pictures for NTT Docomo’s mobile internet service. Nobody knew it yet, but the genie was out of the bottle, and texting would never be the same.

Things went global in 2010 when emojis were added to Unicode, the shared standard that makes text show up the same way on any device. For the first time, everyone was speaking the same emoji dialect, and the stage was set for world domination.

Shigetaka Kurita emoji sketches

Shigetaka Kurita sketches for NTT DOCOMO.

Then came the big bang. In 2011, Apple rolled out its emoji keyboard to iPhone users worldwide, and Android caught up in 2013, putting emojis in the pockets of millions. There was no stopping them after that. They crept into every language and culture on a screen, and nobody has looked at an eggplant or a peach the same way since. They’re still evolving today, quietly rewriting how we talk to each other and getting the message across even when we don’t share a language.

Why your brain can’t unsee it

Pavlov rang a bell, and his dogs started drooling. Brands run a gentler version of that experiment on all of us with emojis. It’s a quiet move, but it has a strong effect. Say you’re thumbing through your feed and a little coffee cup emoji scrolls past. Odds are your brain jumps straight to Morning Brew, the media brand that sold for $75M. That jump is no accident. They claimed the coffee emoji ☕️ as their own. beehiiv, the fast-shipping email platform, ran the same play with the bee 🐝. Two humble little symbols, both now pulling serious weight as branding tools.

Frantic man at a conspiracy board of coffee, bee and alien emojis, captioned “your brain after a week online”

Me, explaining emoji branding at a dinner party.

The secret sauce is repetition plus association. Put the same symbol next to your name enough times, and eventually the emoji does the remembering for your audience. Each time a follower catches that coffee cup or that buzzing bee, the link between symbol and brand gets a little stronger. Do it consistently and your brand earns a permanent seat in their head, tagging along to every group chat, inbox, and feed they open.

Numbers back this. Take email subject lines, for example. Readers are three times as likely to pick the one with emojis in it. Hard to argue with that. So here’s the takeaway: treat your emoji like a brand asset, use it with some personality, and you become very hard to forget.

Morning Brew poured the first cup

Your friend texts, “Grabbing coffee, want one?” and somewhere in the back of your head, a tiny voice whispers Morning Brew. If that’s ever happened to you, congratulations. You’ve been successfully branded.

The daily business and tech newsletter, started by Austin Rief and Alex Lieberman and now read by millions, picked the coffee emoji early and never let go. It sits in their social handles, it leads their subject lines, and it gets sprinkled pretty much anywhere else it fits. There’s a method to the caffeine.

Here’s why it works so well:

  • It pops off the screen: One emoji cuts through a wall of text, so you know whose post it is before you’ve read a word.

  • The whole team carries it: Every employee who adds the mug to their profile is one more place the brand shows up.

  • It becomes the default: See it enough and any mention of coffee, however random, sends your mind straight back to them.

And they didn’t stop at the ☕️ emoji. Readers get a name of their own, the #BrewCrew, which turns a subscriber list into something closer to a club. Very clever.

beehiiv’s hive mind

If the bee strategy feels familiar, there’s a reason. beehiiv’s co-founder and CEO, Tyler Denk, was one of Morning Brew’s early hires, so he’d watched the coffee-cup trick work up close. He borrowed the play, swapped the mug for a 🐝, and gave the brand a buzzing little mascot. In a pretty short time, beehiiv turned its early momentum into a real community of fans, and that bee has done more than its fair share of the heavy lifting. Here’s how they keep the hive buzzing.

  • The founder sets the tone: Tyler is a social media machine and the most recognizable face of the brand on X.

  • The team wears the badge: Employees are nudged to add the bee to their profiles, so it shows up everywhere they post. As Bella Rose Mortel from the social team put it, “Employee advocacy is the one that really sets us apart.”

  • The brand account has fun: The company handle mixes memes, humor, and genuinely useful posts, and the audience eats it up.

The payoff reaches well past growth, too. It’s done wonders for hiring. Tyler explains it well.

❝

Our team has deep personal relationships with hundreds of our users online. We receive tons of qualified candidates for each new role we promote. None of those things would be possible if I chose to build beehiiv in stealth.

Tyler Denk

A couple more emoji all-stars


Chili Piper brings the heat

Emoji branding has spread well past newsletters and creator tools. Chili Piper, a B2B SaaS company in a corner of tech not exactly famous for its sense of fun, has gone all in on the 🌶️, and the team wears the pepper proudly on their social profiles. Just look at all these spicy little chilis.


Hollywood joins the chat: Deadpool

Ahead of the release, the evil geniuses running Deadpool’s marketing covered billboards and social feeds with three characters: 💀💩L.

Say it out loud and you get Deadpool. The joke was dumb in exactly the right way, perfectly in character for the movie, and easy for anyone to crack. A stunt like that could easily have flopped. With a character this irreverent and an audience already in on the joke, it landed, and it shows how much mileage a brand can squeeze out of a couple of tiny pictures.

And Athyna phones home

Almost a year ago, my own company, Athyna, went through this exact exercise. We help companies hire remote talent and train AI models and take our name from a Greek goddess, so we sat down for a branding session to find our emoji.

The early contenders were the genie 🧞‍♂️ (powerful, a little godlike), the crystal ball 🔮 (which I had a weird soft spot for), and the globe 🌎 for the global team angle. In the end, none of them made the cut. We went with what is weirdly described as the ‘alien monster’ emoji 👾.

Athyna’s Slack post announcing its new brand and official emoji, the 👾, and asking staff to update their profiles
Athyna team replies congratulating the rebrand, full of 👾 alien monster emojis

Also known as the Space Invader emoji, this little purple alien represents vintage video games, retro arcade culture, and pixel art, alongside general quirks or weirdness. To me, though, it also represents technology and science fiction, so in the world of AI, it fits (you could argue 🤖 fits better, but it’s just such an ugly emoji).

Picking (and keeping) your emoji

  • Pick one that fits. Look for an emoji that says something about who you are or what you sell, and that nobody in your space already claimed. Bonus points if it’s memorable at first sight.

  • Put it everywhere. Social bios, email signatures, sales decks, even your product if there’s room. Every appearance makes the link a little stronger.

  • Get the team on board. Ask everyone to add it to their professional profiles. A handful of employees can carry the brand a lot further than one company account ever will.

  • Give it a backstory. Tell people why you chose it. A good origin story turns a random symbol into something your audience actually cares about.

  • Make it your own. Turn it into something custom, like a 3D character or an illustrated mascot, so it stands apart from the stock version sitting on everyone’s keyboard.

  • Work it into your campaigns. Hashtags, challenges, launch announcements. The more your marketing leans on it, the stickier it gets.

  • Keep score. Watch brand mentions, engagement, and recall to see whether your emoji is pulling its weight.

Small symbol, big payoff

It’s a small move. One character on a keyboard. But as Morning Brew and beehiiv have shown, if you pick the right emoji and show up with it everywhere, you get a surprising amount of recognition for very little effort.

What I love most is how simple it is. A coffee cup, a bee, a little alien. See any of them often enough next to the same name and your brain files them together for good. And it keeps working quietly in the background, in every feed, inbox, and post, long after you’ve stopped thinking about it.

A man in a tuxedo raises a glass in a toast

Most brands are fighting over the same few seconds of attention, and little signals like this often decide whether you get remembered or scrolled past. So choose carefully, commit fully, and let your emoji move in rent-free. With any luck, it’ll never leave.

And that's it! You can join Open Source CEO here, follow me on Twitter and LinkedIn, and also don’t forget to check out Athyna while you’re at it.

If you enjoyed this post or know someone who may find it useful, please share it with them and encourage them to subscribe: brandchemistry.co/p/why-smart-companies-adopt-an-emoji

Reply

Avatar

or to participate